Culturally Diverse VictimSurvivors of Family Violence Often Charged Falsely, According to New Paper

A new paper released by inTouch has highlighted the concerning and ongoing issue of mis-identification in response to family violence occurring within migrant and refugee communities.

Mis-identification, a key finding in Victoria’s Royal Commission into Family Violence, occurs when the victimsurvivor of family violence is incorrectly identified as the predominant aggressor by law enforcement and the justice system.

It is estimated to occur in every one in ten cases and significantly more when incidents take place in culturally and linguistically diverse communities.

in Touch Multicultural Centre Against Family Violence has been working with migrant and refugee women who are experiencing family violence for over 37 years and have seen many cases of mis-identification occur throughout this time.

Fortunately, after the recommendations made by the Royal Commission into Family Violence, misidentification is an issue that is slowly garnering more attention,” inTouch CEO, Michal Morris said. “However, at least a third of our clients have reported being incorrectly identified as the primary or predominant aggressor at some point in their journey through the justice system.”

This can occur when law enforcement are responding to or investigating an incident and due to language or cultural barriers, there is not a clear understanding of who is in need of protection. If you add extreme emotional distress or physical selfdefence to that situation, a police officer will often misconstrue the situation and arrest the wrong person the victimsurvivor.”

As the inTouch position paper details, misidentification can have a number of farreaching and devastating consequences for victimsurvivors. It can result in criminal charges, detrimental legal outcomes, visa loss and a reduction in access to support services some women will even lose custody of their children. Police administration also cannot remove the status of perpetrator from a woman’s record, even when it’s been proven that misidentification occurred.

Correcting instances of misidentification is a lengthy and resourceheavy process and often results in a loss of trust in the law enforcement and justice systems, making it unlikely for women to contact police for assistance should violence occur in the future. inTouch’s paper makes a number of key recommendations, informed by the organisation’s extensive experience working with migrant and refugee women experiencing family violence.

In order to address family violence effectively, we must acknowledge that it occurs across every community and culture,” Ms Morris said. “Furthermore, law enforcement and the justice system must be equipped with the capacity and training to respond to family violence with culturally appropriate procedure and practice.

Issues covered in the paper include:

Why misidentificationof the predominant aggressoroccurs
  Communities at high risk of misidentification

  Different types of misidentification, and how this can be manipulated by a perpetrator of violence (including systems abuse)

Consequences of misidentification on the victim survivor

Effect of COVID19

Steps required to reduces instances of misidentification.

inTouch’s position paper, The Causes and Consequences of Misidentification on Women From Migrant and Refugee Communities Experiencing Family Violence can be read here.